Assessing Crisis Conditions and Revitalisation Needs through a Multi-Criteria Approach: Evidence from Municipalities in the Silesian Voivodeship, Poland
Purpose: The purpose of this study is to assess and compare the socioeconomic, economic, environmental, spatial-functional and technical conditions associated with revitalisation and sustainable development across different types of municipalities in the Silesian Voivodeship, Poland. Particular attention is given to identifying differences in the relative development positions of municipalities and examining their changes over the period 2015–2023. Design/Methodology/Approach: The study combines a narrative review of the literature on revitalisation and sustainable development with an empirical, indicator-based analysis. Secondary statistical data obtained from Statistics Poland (GUS) through the STRATEG Development Monitoring System are used to construct a multidimensional assessment framework. The analysis covers four types of municipalities: cities with county rights, urban municipalities, urban–rural municipalities and rural municipalities. The Technique for Order Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution (TOPSIS), a multi-criteria decision-making method, is applied to develop synthetic indicators and establish comparative rankings over the analysed period. Findings: The results reveal considerable differences in the relative positions of municipalities and a stable ordering of municipality types throughout the study period. Cities with county rights achieved the highest aggregate TOPSIS scores, followed by urban–rural and rural municipalities, while urban municipalities recorded the lowest scores. At the individual level, Mysłowice consistently ranked first among cities with county rights, whereas Łaziska Górne occupied the last position among urban municipalities. Pszczyna maintained the leading position among urban–rural municipalities, while Goczałkowice-Zdrój led the rural group until 2022, being replaced by Psary in 2023. The findings demonstrate the value of a multidimensional approach to comparing local development conditions while highlighting the importance of considering territorial characteristics when interpreting composite indicators. Practical Implications: The proposed assessment framework can support local authorities and regional policymakers in identifying municipalities that require more detailed diagnostic attention and in informing the design of sustainable development and revitalisation strategies. The results may also facilitate comparative monitoring of local conditions and help identify areas where targeted social, economic, environmental and infrastructural interventions could be considered. However, municipality-level rankings should be complemented by more detailed territorial analyses before specific revitalisation areas or intervention priorities are designated. Originality/Value: The study contributes to research on sustainable revitalisation by providing a longitudinal, multi-criteria comparison of four types of municipalities within a post-industrial region of Poland. Its originality lies in integrating five dimensions relevant to revitalisation into a consistent TOPSIS-based assessment framework and examining the evolution of municipalities' relative positions over nine years. The research also highlights the analytical distinction between municipality-level development conditions and the identification of legally designated degraded areas, offering a basis for further research into the relationship between local development characteristics and sustainable revitalisation policies.