Human Capital, Debt Aversion, and Signaling: Student Deviations from the Rational-Investor Model against an LLM Contrastive Benchmark (Homo Silicus)
Purpose: This paper tests empirical deviations in decisions made by students at a Polish public university from the assumptions of the student-as-investor model derived from human capital theory. Design/Methodology/Approach: Drawing on a scenario-based (vignette) questionnaire covering economic, academic and relational dilemmas, administered to a sample of N = 218 respondents, we analyse three patterns with a clear economic interpretation: debt aversion coupled with the privatisation of the costs of education, an instrumental attitude toward knowledge consistent with signalling logic, and the primacy of intra-family transfers over the return on educational investment. As a contrastive decision benchmark we use the Minitaur cognitive foundation model (Llama-3.1-Minitaur-8B, the small version of Centaur), treated in the spirit of the Homo silicus notion, that is, as a computational proxy for a decision-maker trained on data from psychological experiments rather than as an analytic optimum of Homo economicus. Response probability distributions were obtained through deterministic logit extraction, enabling a distributional rather than merely modal comparison between humans and the model. Findings: The divergences are statistically significant in chi-square goodness-of-fit tests against the model distribution, with Cohen’s w effect sizes ranging from 0.48 to 1.07; because the same respondents answered every scenario, any aggregate chi-square is treated only as a descriptive summary rather than a formal omnibus test. The observed pattern, oriented toward the avoidance of debt and institutions, toward instrumentalism, and toward relational obligations, is interpreted as an indicator of structural boundary conditions omitted by the rational-investor model and is synthesised in terms of survival rationality: an adaptive logic of minimising the risk of irreversible losses that complements, rather than negates, the rational-investor model. We explicitly acknowledge the competing hypothesis that part of the divergence is of artefactual origin, reflecting the culturally situated (WEIRD) character of the language model. Practical Implications: Policies aimed at students should design debt instruments that are sensitive to debt aversion, such as income-contingent repayment schemes, and should address the gap between the formal availability of institutional resources (loans, leaves of absence, university infrastructure) and their limited actual uptake. Originality/Value: The study introduces a large language model as a contrastive decision benchmark in the sense of Homo silicus, using deterministic logit extraction to enable a distributional rather than modal human–model comparison, and reframes the observed deviations through the lens of survival rationality as an adaptive complement to the rational-investor model.